Free Speech Should Not Mean “Mandated” Speech


Under the guise of "Sunshine" and "Free Speech" Florida's newspapers are engaging in the worst form of hypocrisy.

The Florida Press Association is opposing a proposed change to the law that would remove the Florida state mandate that local governments (using taxpayer dollars) pay for advertising space in printed newspapers.

If you are reading this, chances are you are reading it online. The fact is that no newspaper would dare publish such an opinion piece. It is also a fact that newspapers all across America recognize the power and the utility of online resources. They also recognize that more and more people get their news from online sources. They know this and as a result they are changing the very foundation of who they are and how they conduct their business. Yes, they themselves are rapidly changing and moving to provide more and more online news and news-related services.

But they don't want local government to change and that is the hypocrisy.

For years, it has been state law that local governments are required to buy ads in local (print) newspapers to notify the public of public meetings and other such matters. For the record, public notification and open public meetings is a very good thing, but let's be honest, does anyone really read the public notifications stuffed in the back of the local (print edition) paper? Or are those interested at such a high level of the goings on in government equally likely to find such notices on line? This is not a case against public notice, it is a case in support of providing local government the same flexibility that newspapers themselves have and allowing them the same options that everyone else is exploring.

So if newspapers are changing and moving to an online format, why shouldn't local governments be allowed the same opportunity?

Each year, cities and counties all across Florida are forced to spend (dare I say "waste"?) millions - yes millions - of taxpayer dollars paying for legal notices in printed newspapers. Notices that almost nobody reads.

These nearly worthless state-mandated legal notices are not just a vestigial tradition dating back to the turn of the century, they amount to a government subsidy to help keep failing newspapers afloat. There is no real good reason for cities, counties, school boards and other local bodies to use tax dollars to buy advertisements that serve no legitimate public purpose.

State lawmakers need to loosen the reins and give local governments the same flexibility to notice public meetings in a way that a) doesn't cost taxpayers millions of dollars and b) actually reaches those citizens who care.

So what options could local governments use?

For starters, email notification, online ads in papers, posting on the governments' websites, postings at the government buildings, notifications on local government TV channels...heck, hot air balloons if it got people's attention.

The fact is that the state mandates that school boards, sheriff offices, county and city commissions to name a few, MUST, as a matter of law, run and pay for advertising in print in local newspapers. It is ironic that some of those very newspapers are strong supporters of free speech and the first amendment to the U.S. Constitution and are offering editorial positions in opposition to changing this bad law.

Without a doubt, the first amendment to our country's Constitution stands as one of our most important freedoms, but there is a world of difference between freedom of speech and speech that is mandated.


Our Cities in Action

Dec-29-2013 The Ledger
Lakeland will complete the year with a goal it announced almost 30 years ago: a population of more than 100,000.
Nov-20-2013 Reuters
Only third city in the nation to receive Palladium honor. The City of Tamarac, Florida has joined the ranks of such prestigious organizations as Motorola, UPS and Hilton Hotels as a recipient of the...
Sep-16-2013 Tampa Bay Times
Shelby Willis is 5 feet 4 inches tall. But that didn't stop her from climbing up the ranks to become Largo's first female fire chief and the only female fire chief in Pinellas County.
Sep-03-2013 Daily Commercial
Eustis city commissioners will meet Thursday night to consider creating a Downtown Waterfront Entertainment District to better promote the city and help local businesses.
Aug-02-2013 Daytona Beach News-Journal
DAYTONA BEACH — As the city comes alive with a massive redevelopment at Daytona International Speedway and the promise of two new oceanfront hotels, the 85-year-old Boardwalk is basking in a rebirth...
May-07-2013 South Florida Business Journal
Fort Lauderdale has been ranked No. 7 for economic potential on a list of the Top 10 Small American Cities of the Future, according to fDi Magazine.
Apr-11-2013 South Florida Sun-Sentinel
Tours in South Florida typically go to the beach but, in Coral Springs, city leaders will pile onto a bus to see government buildings in three counties. City commissioners haven't decided yet to...
Apr-05-2013 Tampa Bay Times
Family, friends and residents will gather at 2:30 p.m. Sunday for the official renaming of “John R. Lawrence Pioneer Park.”
Apr-03-2013 Longboat Observer
A town Fire Rescue Department software application is in a Computerworld Honors Program Safety & Security category with the likes of Hewlett-Packard and the FBI.
Mar-27-2013 Belleair Bee
BELLEAIR - The town of Belleair is encouraging veterans and active military personnel to be on hand at the April 2 commission meeting when the town proclaims April 17 as Military Family and Community...